10 Top Ice Cream Spots in NJ

Nothing compares to the refreshing taste of a frosty ice cream cone any time of the year! From over-the-top sundaes to unique homemade flavors, there are some NJ ice cream shops that tend to stand out from the rest. So, here’s the scoop on the 10 top ice cream spots in NJ. 

Nicholas Creamery

Atlantic Highlands, Fair Haven, and Tinton Falls

Known best for their small-batch ice cream, Nicholas Creamery puts love and care into every order they serve. Using all-natural, premium ingredients, their creative flavors are constantly changing. Do keep in mind, this is a cash-only shop, but next time you are nearby, consider trying a scoop of their brown sugar bourbon or buttermilk lemon blueberry in one of their made-in-shop waffle cones.

top ice cream spots in NJ

Milk & Cream Cereal Bar

Jersey City

Even though their menu only mentions vanilla and cookie dough soft serve, Milk & Cream Cereal Bar’s cereal-infused swirls will satisfy all your sweet cravings. Not only do these camera-ready treats taste just as good as they look but the extensive amount of possible frozen creations are seemingly endless. Whether you are one to stick to your favorite combination or change things up every visit, the delicious and unconventional ice cream options keep you coming back for more.

top ice cream spots in NJ

The Baked Bear

Long Branch

This shop is guaranteed to raise your expectations of a simple ice cream sandwich to the next level. The Baked Bear makes all the ice cream, cookies, and brownies used to create their massive ice cream sandwiches by hand, and the cookies and brownies are served while they are still warm. Give the giant ice cream sandwiches a try, or have a smaller portion with their open-faced ice cream sandwich, the bear bowl. 

top ice cream spots in NJ

The Bent Spoon


If you’re looking for a heavenly dessert spot for this summer, this could be your go-to place from our top ice cream spots in NJ list. Apart from the classic chocolate, vanilla, and strawberry, The Bent Spoon also has a ton of special seasonal flavors made with local and organic ingredients, such as rhuberry, mango lassi, and beet with chocolate chunks. The scoops here are not overly sweet and deliver a lot of great flavor. Plus, you can also get your fix of cupcakes, cookies, and sorbets as well. A fan favorite here has to be the lavender mascarpone, but regardless, they are bound to have something for everybody.

top ice cream spots in NJ

Owowcow Creamery


With a made-from-scratch ice cream base and more than 20 artisan flavors made daily, Owowcow Creamery offers a variety of fresh ice cream. The locals and regulars love it here, and any Owowcow veterans can vouch for their tasty, creamy, and locally-sourced flavors. Be sure to try their strawberry salted stracciatella, cookie monstah, or almond coconut chocolate chip when you decide to visit. 

top ice cream spots in NJ

Coney Waffle

Asbury Park, Belmar, Long Branch, and Red Bank

When it comes to loaded sundaes, it is hard to top the selection at Coney Waffle. You can totally ask for a plain scoop of monkey bizness or salted caramel pretzel, but they are better known for their highly-decorated, Instagrammable cones, milkshakes, and ice cream cakes with all kinds of sugary sweets. Of course, you would have to make room for a waffle topped with ice cream or cannoli cream. From cotton candy and gummy bears to ice cream sandwiches and full-size Hershey bars as topping options, prepare yourself for a chilly and yummy sugar rush!

top ice cream spots in NJ

Surreal Creamery

New Brunswick

A better ice cream spot than Surreal Creamery for ice cream and bubble tea lovers? Impossible. With traditional soft serve twists along with specialties like earl grey, taro, and matcha, their bubble tea and ice cream floats as well as their mason jar sundaes are delicious and aesthetically pleasing. Plus, the portion sizes are generous for their price, so feel free to share with a friend. 

top ice cream spots in NJ

Duffer’s Restaurant & Homemade Ice Cream Parlour


For those spending summer on the Jersey shore, Duffer’s should be on the top of your must-do top ice cream spots in NJ list. Not only is all the ice cream made in house and served in huge potions but you could also grab lunch or dinner and some mini golf and arcade games. However, Duffer’s is best known for their ice cream, so you could just as easily go for their ice cream and take it to go. Just don’t leave Wildwood without trying one of their sundaes, floats, or shakes!

top ice cream spots in NJ

Milk Sugar Love

Jersey City

Regardless of what treat you pick here, it is always said to be made organically with milk, sugar, and – you probably guessed it – love. Milk Sugar Love’s ice cream offers their own all-natural flavors, like midnight cocoa, lemon olive oil, and hazelnut chip. There are also unique ice cream sandwiches, such as The Fruity Pebble Mac Daddy that is made between two homemade macaroons. If you choose to visit, you will surely taste the love in every frozen bite of this ice cream.

top ice cream spots in NJ

Cookman Creamery

Asbury Park

Last but certainly not least, Cookman Creamery is worth a mention in the top ice cream spots in NJ for their selection of both traditional and vegan ice cream for your taste buds’ pleasure. With such an enticing selection of options, such as devil’s food, PB monster, vegan key lime pie, and vegan blue lavender, there is bound to be a favorite for everyone’s flavor preferences.

top ice cream spots in NJ

In the end, you truly can’t go wrong with any of these top ice cream spots in NJ. Now, the hardest decision you will have to make is which flavors you want to try from each! Hopefully, our list of favorites will help you and your family find your own. Once you find that perfect frozen treat, it will surely make your heart melt and keep you from melting away in the warm summer weather. 


Read more here.